Killing Mountain Lions Won t Protect Livestock. Being More Responsible Will.

P-45 in the Santa Monica Mountains | Photo: National Park Service

[Editors note: This commentary is prompted by a ranchers move to kill one of the Santa Monica Mountains beleaguered mountain lions after one or more of those lions killed ten alpacas and a goat. As we published this piece, the owner of the unfortunate livestock was reportedly negotiating an alternative, non-lethal response to the puma depredation. We will update this story as necessary.]

Biologist Alessandra Soresina spent much of the late 1990s and early 2000s driving around looking for big cats. She knew the local feline population well enough that eventually shed amassed massive files on each individual. She knew their movements, she knew which cats were friends with which other cats, and shed even made some guesses as to the structure of their family trees. But sometimes after seeing an individual two or three times in a year, theyd disappear. Entire social groups would collapse.

The cats that Soresina was after were not mountain lions, but African lions, and she wasnt driving around the Santa Monica Mountains, but Tanzanias Tarangire National Park.

At first, Soresina blamed the hunting blocks that lied just outside the parks boundaries. Lions born inside the park would eventually wander onto private property where they became fair game for a wealthy trophy hunter. Its a compelling way to explain the males with their impressive manes who would disappear. But why were the females disappearing just as often?

Share on FacebookShare on TwitterSend EmailMoreCommentPin on PinterestShare on LinkedInShare on Google+

--

--

As University of Minnesota lion researcher Craig Packer explains in his book Lions in the Balance, Soresina was right that the local lion population was disappearing, but her explanation proved ultimately incorrect. It wasnt the hunters who were responsible for decimating the so-called King of the Jungle. It was the others who lived just outside the park: Maasai pastoralists.

African lions are no dummies. Their typical prey, like impala or wildebeest, requires quite a bit of energy to hunt. These hoofed creatures have evolved an awareness of the threat posed by lions. They remain vigilant, always ready to run - fast - at a moments notice. So if a lion comes across a domestic cow or goat, creatures unprepared for the threat of lion predation, and ill equipped to escape, it's a no-brainer. The lion can enjoy an easy meal without having to work for it. When this happens, many Maasai kill a lion in retaliation.

Many of the lions tracked by Soresina ultimately met their end when confronted with the tip of a Maasai spear. Others were poisoned.

Down to as few as 20,000 individuals worldwide, African lions (Panthera leo) have been relegated to just 17 percent of their historical range in Africa. While mainstream news headlines might lead you to believe that legalized trophy hunting is their main problem, the species (classified as threatened by the IUCN) suffers from habitat loss, depletion of prey, and retaliatory killing for the real or perceived losses of livestock, among other threats.

More about mountain lions

Finding Californias Worst Highways For Wildlife

A Tale of Two Mountain Lions

L.A.s Mountain Lions Can Survive, If They Can Cross The 101

1 of 6

next

Mountain lions (Puma concolor), on the other hand, arent doing so badly. The IUCN classifies them as a species of least concern, and while theyve been pushed out of most of their historic range in North America, theyve retained footholds in the American West through Central America, and all the way down to the southernmost tip of Chile. But the local population in the Southland tells a different story. Because the Santa Monica Mountains form an isolated island hemmed in by an ocean of concrete and cars, the local population of cougars faces a 15-22 percent chance of dying out in fifty years. By 2065, the risk skyrockets to 99.7 percent. In many ways, our cougars are worse off than Africas lions.

Earlier this week, reports surfaced that a mountain lion probably killed a herd of alpacas and a goat in the hills of Malibu. While there are plenty of mule deer for the mountain lions to eat, like their African cousins, these cats are no dummies. Why work hard for a meal when theres a literal buffet waiting behind a fence where they cant escape? Indeed, as NPS explains, at least four local lions have been implicated in livestock predation events recently. Even P-22 snuck a koala when he thought no one was looking.

Despite some reports, this is not aberrant behavior, but altogether predictable. Mountain lions dont discern much of a difference between an alpaca and a deer-just that penned animals are much easier to catch, said Beth Pratt-Bergstrom, California Director for the National Wildlife Federation.

While the California Department of Fish and Wildlife (CDFW) concurs that a mountain lion appears responsible for these unfortunate deaths, and the National Park Service (NPS) confirms that a male called P-45 was in the area during the night in question, DNA evidence has not yet identified the individual lion responsible. Indeed, mountain lions use every inch of the little habitat available to them in the Santa Monicas, with overlapping territories much smaller than would be the case in a larger landscape. It could have been one of a number of lions.

As is their right under state law, the owner of the alpacas requested a depredation permit from CDFW. Obligated to do so, CDFW then granted the permit. According to CDFW spokesperson Steve Gonzalez, the permit allows the property owner (domestic livestock are considered property) to hire a hunter to kill the mountain lion within ten days, within a radius of ten miles from the incident. However, Gonzalez says, the depredation permit was issued for one mountain lion, not any particular mou

LINK:	https://www.kcet.org/redefine/shooting-las-mountain-lions-wont-protect...
	See more stories from kcet

More from KCET