AoIP and the road to true IP interoperability
29/08/2019
As IP connectivity becomes increasingly widespread and more accessible to all sectors of our industry, those with their sights set on the true goals of interoperability are working hard to play together. AES67 defines a common language for the streaming of live, high-quality low-latency audio over IP. But what are we doing to manage the transition from traditional connectivity, and how do we achieve the full benefits that have been promised with IP workflows?
A key touted advantage of moving to IP is the ability to use existing network infrastructures and COTS (Commercial-Off-The-Shelf) hardware. Broadcasters want to be able to pass audio, video, control and other data over shared IP networks, and they want to use open standards to do so between devices made by different manufacturers. Standardised IP connectivity eradicates much of the cost, space, system complexity and cabling overhead of having a multitude of interfaces for analogue, AES3, MADI, SDI, etc. This is the goal of both AES67 and ST2110.
AoIP has been around for many years, with lots of broadcasters already relying on it daily to produce live on-air content. In many cases, it's been radio stations that have been pioneering the way in terms of full IP system-wide integration, as well as the linking of geographically remote facilities, with flagship examples like the BBC's Virtual Local Radio (ViLoR) project. This is in part because radio has not been held back by the video over IP debate of ST2022-6 (SDI over IP) vs ST2110 (separate RTP streams for video, AES67-audio and metadata) that has been going on in the TV world. Also, the bandwidth requirements of audio are negligible compared to that of video, making the network infrastructure considerably more affordable.
Although AoIP networking is on the increase, there's still a tendency to go for single-manufacturer solutions, ensuring all the devices have the same parameter set and interpretation of AES67, with the same discovery and connection management methods. This makes successful deployment easier and provides a clear line of technical support from the vendor. However, this leaves broadcasters feeling tied to their investment and it isn't the true goal of IP; if you've bought 10 HP PCs, you would not be concerned about going out and buying a Dell, at least in terms of whether it will be able to access, edit and share the same files. IP broadcast equipment should be no different.
In TV, audio equipment has to interface with a wider range of kit from vendors in different fields, which has highlighted the challenges of interoperability further.
So what's missing? AES67 gives us a standardised protocol and parameter set that means for example a Wheatnet device can exchange audio streams with a Livewire device as both can be configured to operate within the bounds of AES67, though it's not necessarily simple to connect stream connections between different vendors. It typically requires an engineer to configure output streams on each device and often manually entering complex configuration details to be able to receive streams from other devices. While this works reliably, it relies on engineers to set up and it results in a static streaming configuration. For dynamic routing of audio, providing the operational workflows needed for live broadcast, we're still relying on expensive broadcast routers, albeit IP. This is not the goal of using COTS IP.
With AES3, you plug in a BNC, and the receiving device knows it is expecting two channels of audio on that connection. With AoIP, a single connection to a network allows for the exchange of lots of channels of audio with lots of different pieces of equipment, but you can only receive that audio if you know it exists in the first place. The fundamental part missing from both AES67 and ST-2110 is advertisement and connection management. In the absence of an agreed standard, many, but not all vendors have followed the Ravenna approach, which is helpful for advertising AoIP streams between those vendors, but this still leaves us with labour intensive configuration and static streaming connections.
This is where the likes of AIMS (Alliance for IP Media Solutions) and the JT-NM (Joint Task Force on Networked Media) become very important. They are promoting full interoperability including NMOS, a standardised mechanism for not only discovery/advertisement (NMOS IS-04), but also connection management (NMOS IS-05), from a centralised point, meaning you do not have to log in to each device on a network to configure its connections, but instead have a user-friendly UI capable of dynamically routing streams between devices from different manufacturers - using the network to perform the routing function.
NMOS has gained strong buy-in across the industry, from both manufacturers and broadcasters. It's widely seen as the route to true interoperability, but its uptake has been slow in some areas.
As broadcast equipment manufacturers, true interoperability could be perceived as a threat because it increases competition. We defend our market share by making reliable, high performing and easy-to-use products with a feature set designed for live broadcast applications, not by needlessly implementing proprietary or unique methods. To unlock the full potential of IP and give broadcasters the workflows, costs and efficiency savings they need to compete in the modern broadcast era, we must all work together, fully and properly implementing the agreed standards to provide proven multi-vendor systems that are easy for operational staff to use. At Calrec we are working with our partners and following the JT-NM roadmap - our Type R, IP-native radio system being a prime example working towards the ultimate goals of making life better for our customers.
LINK: | https://calrec.com/blog/aoip-and-the-road-to-true-ip-interoperability/... |
See more stories from calrec |
Most recent headlines
15/01/2025
Canon Unveils Camera Color-Matching Application
MELVILLE, N.Y. Canon USA has announced key features and availability for its new Camera Color Matching Application, a powerful new Windows-compatible software a...
15/01/2025
Altice's Optimum Complains to FCC Over Nexstar Retrans Negotiations
NEW YORK Altice USA has sent a letter to the Federal Communications Commission complaining about Nexstar's handling of retransmission consent negotiations, ...
15/01/2025
Heartland Video Systems Buys Videstra
PLYMOUTH, Wisc. Heartland Video Systems (HVS) has acquired Videstra, a company that offers solutions to integrate micro-local cameras for weather, towers and tr...
15/01/2025
NAB Show Opens Registration, Launches New Sports Summit
WASHINGTON The National Association of Broadcasters said registration is open for the 2025 NAB Show, which will bring the global media and entertainment industr...
15/01/2025
West Virginia AG Reaches $119.5 Million Settlement with Altice USA
CHARLESTON, W. Va. After a multi-year investigation, West Virginia Attorney General Patrick Morrisey has reached a $119.5 million settlement with Altice USA to ...
15/01/2025
Curl Commercial Shot on Blackmagic Cinema Camera 6K
Cur l Commercial Shot on Blackmagic Cinema Camera 6K Brie Clayton January 14, 2025 0 Comments Japanese skincare brand's new web commercial shot in...
15/01/2025
New BLAM Release Set to Transform End-to-End Workflow Management
New BLAM Release Set to Transform End-to-End Workflow Management Brie Clayton January 14, 2025 0 Comments Blue Lucy's recent software update for o...
14/01/2025
L3Harris Unveils New Resilient Waveform Package
Available today and interoperable with the RF-7850 Family of Radios, Vanguard and Vapor fill a critical requirement for secure and survivable multi-domain wideb...
14/01/2025
L3Harris to Provide Integrated Platform Management System for Royal Australian Navy Frigates
Rendering of Hunter Class frigate at sea. Image credit: BAE...
14/01/2025
EdgeBeam Wireless ATSC 3.0 Datacasting Hits the Ground Running
It's still early days for EdgeBeam Wireless, the joint venture of E.W. Scripps Co., Sinclair, Gray Media and Nexstar Media Group aiming to deliver datacasti...
14/01/2025
DirecTV Launches MySports Streamer
DirecTV has announced the launch of MySports, a new sports streaming service featuring 40 sports and broadcast channels. For $50 per month, it is initially av...
14/01/2025
Comscore Expands Local Measurement Deal with Coastal Television
RESTON, Va. Comscore has announced a new deal with Coastal Television's Media Group to provide of TV measurement and advanced audience data across 12 of Coa...
14/01/2025
Digital Alert Systems Adds Daniel Dillon as Product and Project Manager
LYNDONVILLE, N.Y. Emergency communications solutions provider Digital Alert Systems has tapped Daniel Dillon as a product and project manager....
14/01/2025
NESN Turns To Bitcentral Core News for Content Management
NEWPORT BEACH, Calif. New England Sports Network (NESN) has partnered with Bitcentral to add state-of-the-art media management and production tools to its opera...
14/01/2025
The Spring Signature Series Presents Kendrick Scott Berklee Ensemble
The Spring Signature Series Presents Kendrick Scott Berklee Ensemble The acclaimed percussionist has toured and collaborated with jazz legends Herbie Handcock...
14/01/2025
Ross Video Buys EagleEye Cable Camera Business, Technology
OTTAWA, Canada Ross Video has acquired EagleEye from sec.swiss (Swiss Electronic Creation), a strategic move that enhances its portfolio of camera motion system...
14/01/2025
How UNIT created a CG photoreal gorilla for Paramount+ drama Stags
UNIT VFX supervisor Nuno Pereira tells TVBEurope about the work that went into creating an emotive CG gorilla called El Ni o By Jenny Priestley Published: Ja...
14/01/2025
Vizio Launches App Bundle With Discounted Starz, AMC+ Offer
IRVINE, Calif. Vizio has launched a new bundled app on its TV that gives viewers access to the vast selection of movies and TV shows in the Starz and AMC+ libra...
14/01/2025
T-Mobile Ramps Up Ad Business With $600 Million Vistar Media Acquisition
BELLEVUE, Wash. T-Mobile is further expanding its advertising business with the announcement that it has entered into a definitive agreement to acquire Vistar M...
14/01/2025
Comcast NBCUniversal Donates $10 Million to Support L.A. Wildfire Relief
LOS ANGELES Comcast NBCUniversal said it will donate $10 million in cash to support Los Angeles-area wildfire disaster relief and recovery efforts....
14/01/2025
Scripps' Brian Lawlor To Receive 2025 Golden Mic Award
NEW YORK The Broadcasters Foundation of America said that Scripps Sports President Brian Lawlor will receive its 2025 Golden Mic Award, presented at the group...
14/01/2025
Live on Wednesday: Behind the VFX Scenes of UFO Sweden
Live on Wednesday: Behind the VFX Scenes of UFO Sweden Brie Clayton January 13, 2025 0 Comments Uncover the truth behind UFO Sweden's cutting-ed...
14/01/2025
A.I. Search in Seconds
A.I. Search in Seconds Michael Cioni January 13, 2025 0 Comments How much time do you spend sifting through hours and hours of footage? What if you di...
14/01/2025
Healthcare Leaders, NVIDIA CEO Share AI Innovation Across the Industry
AI is making inroads across the entire healthcare industry - from genomic research to drug discovery, clinical trial workflows and patient care. In a fireside ...
14/01/2025
NVIDIA GTC 2025: Quantum Day to Illuminate the Future of Quantum Computing
Quantum computing is one of the most exciting areas in computer science, promising progress in accelerated computing beyond what's considered possible today...
14/01/2025
UKTV Ventures partners with digital community for the over 50s, Rest Less, in airtime-for-equity deal
Leading multi-channel broadcaster UKTV has today announced it has invested in Re...
14/01/2025
5VREAL: EMG / Gravity Media Italy and Vodafone Contribute to Innovative Sports Analysis and Fan Engagement Project
5VREAL: EMG / Gravity Media Italy and Vodafone contribute to innovative sports a...
14/01/2025
SMPTE Elects Richard Welsh as President
SMPTE Elects Richard Welsh as President By Ken Kerschbaumer, Editorial Director Tuesday, January 14, 2025 - 9:44 am Print This Story | Subscribe Story H...
14/01/2025
Cromorama's Pablo Garcia Sees Ennio as a Solution to HDR/SDR Complexity
Cromorama's Pablo Garcia Sees Ennio as a Solution to HDR/SDR Complexity The color-conversion tool manages switching between formats across multiple channels...
14/01/2025
Canon Intros Color Matching Application for CR-N700 PTZ Camera
Canon Intros Color Matching Application for CR-N700 PTZ Camera Software simplifies consistency with main production camera By Ken Kerschbaumer, Editorial Direc...
14/01/2025
Fox Sports Australia Goes Ultra-Wide Screen as PCB Digital Installs Magna Systems LED Screen
Fox Sports Australia Goes Ultra-Wide Screen as PCB Digital Installs Magna System...
14/01/2025
What's Next: How Live Game Broadcasts are Redefining Fan Engagement
What's Next: How Live Game Broadcasts are Redefining Fan Engagement Leaders from CBS Sports, FOX Sports, Warner Bros. Discovery, the NBA, and CAA share thei...
14/01/2025
NEP Group's Josh Liemer on the Connected Solutions Rebrand, Another Season of MLS Season Pass
NEP Group's Josh Liemer on the Connected Solutions Rebrand, Another Season o...
14/01/2025
NBC Sports and Olympics' Darryl Jefferson on the Beauty of Paris 2024, Packed 2025 With NBA's Return
NBC Sports and Olympics' Darryl Jefferson on the Beauty of Paris 2024, Packe...
14/01/2025
DIRECTV Launches 40-Channel MySports Package
DIRECTV Launches 40-Channel MySports Package By Ken Kerschbaumer, Editorial Director Tuesday, January 14, 2025 - 2:13 pm Print This Story | Subscribe St...
14/01/2025
Official trailer released for Sky Documentaries three-part series Boyzone: No Matter What
Official trailer released for Sky Documentaries three-part series Boyzone: No Ma...
14/01/2025
New unleashed frequency ranges: Rohde & Schwarz extends broadband amplifiers to 18 GHz
New unleashed frequency ranges: Rohde & Schwarz extends broadband amplifiers to ...
14/01/2025
Happily Never After? I am MarriedBut!' Unveils the Realities of Marriage in Main Trailer
Back to All News Happily Never After? I am Married But!' Unveils the Reali...
14/01/2025
Comscore Expands Local Currency Partnership with Coastal Television's Media Group to Deliver Advanced TV Measurement Across 12 Markets
Comscore Expands Local Currency Partnership with Coastal Television's Media ...
14/01/2025
Ross Video Acquires EagleEye from sec.swiss, Expands Cable Camera Portfolio
Ottawa, Canada - January 14, 2025 - Ross Video, a global leader in live video production, is pleased to announce the acquisition of EagleEye from sec.swiss (swi...
13/01/2025
Nominations open for the Australia for UNHCR - SBS Les Murray Award for Refugee Recognition
Nominations open for the Australia for UNHCR - SBS Les Murray Award for Refugee ...
13/01/2025
Hub Survey: Viewers Want AI Content Labeled
PORTSMOUTH, N.H. A new survey released by Hub Entertainment Research found a majority of viewers want to know when something they're watching was created by...
13/01/2025
AccuWeather Acquires TOA Systems
NEW ORLEANS AccuWeather has acquired TOA Systems, a provider of lightning-detection hardware and one of the few global lightning networks in existence, the comp...
13/01/2025
Webinar: Streamline Digital Asset Management Creativity
Webinar: Streamline Digital Asset Management Creativity Brie Clayton January 13, 2025 0 Comments Santa Cruz Software and Activo to Host Webinar for Cr...
13/01/2025
The Listeners: creating the soundworld of the groundbreaking drama
Sound designer Steve Fanagan tells David Davies how the soundscape behind the recent BBC One series, The Listeners, was created By Contributor Published: Jan...
13/01/2025
Evolve and elevate: the role of standards in bringing immersive video to a wider audience
Philippe Guillotel, director and head of the video lab's metavideo group at ...
13/01/2025
Remembering the legend: how Scanline VFX retold the SENNA story
Craig Wentworth, overall VFX supervisor at Scanline VFX, tells TVBEurope how the spectacular sights and sounds of Formula 1 in the 80s and 90s were recreated fo...
13/01/2025
2025 M&E Trends: What's old is (sometimes) new again
Steve Reynolds, CEO of Imagine Communications, offers a view on the trends he believes will significantly impact the way the media and entertainment industry cr...
13/01/2025
Lisa Nandy looking at alternatives to BBC licence fee'
According to a report, the Secretary of State is considering alternative funding models, including mutualisation By Jenny Priestley Published: January 13, 20...
13/01/2025
Meet the principal solutions architect
Scott Wall, principal solutions architect at Signiant EMEA, details his journey in the media industry - from getting hands-on experience at Glastonbury, to bein...