Finding a Balance as AI Advances
23/07/2024
The event was held under the Chatham House Rule so where someone is named, it is with their explicit permission.
Claus Grewenig, Chief Corporate Affairs Officer at RTL Deutschland co-hosted and shared the perspective of a large broadcasting and streaming company's as well as a news organisation's perspective around:
despite the pros of AI, the need for a robust (copyright) framework to protect and negotiate when content is used
the need for improvements in levelling the playing field and findability for value media
a focus on financial sustainability of the media sector (e.g. no ad restrictions)
Dan Nechita, Head of Cabinet for Dragos Tudorache, MEP with Renew Europe, spoke about how the European Parliament (EP) insisted on provisions for transparency regarding input data to increase our knowledge of how models are trained, about how AI labelling helps combat disinformation and electoral interference, and about the next steps in the AI Act implementation, for which the European Commission (EC), and in particular the AI Office, is in charge.
Kilian Gross, Head of Unit in the AI Office at the EC followed with outlining how the AI Office is a transversal organisation, not just a regulator and is trying to balance innovation and regulation while being inclusive, fast and conscious that actions need to be done with the global context in mind.
Ariane Bernard, a news industry and digital innovation leader who currently advises many News CEOs, spoke about the reality from the trenches where her current clients often express anxiety about the lack of clarity about where things are going which has led many news organisations to be slow or to fall back on a dependency on Big Tech so as not to fall foul of any interpretation of regulation.
Postive role for AI? Participants expressed a series of concerns about the AI world in terms of media sustainability, trust and disinformation as well as copyright concerns. There were many open questions about how regulation could or would play a positive force in the ecosystem overall.
It was acknowledged that AI tools could be positive and help freedom of expression and legitimate news organisations but this was tempered by concerns of how bad actors would use these tools and ignore any regulations. This led to a discussion about journalisms role in explaining AI to a wider audience, while things are moving so quickly - no easy task!
Sonja Schwetje of RTL Deutschland observed that while most media organisations have shown an immense effort catering to the preferences of younger audiences in terms of how and where to provide their content, there remains an ambiguity between balanced, impartial journalistic information and polarising, opinion-based content, with the latter being promoted much more via algorithms.
-- Play
-- --
Dialogue between all parties Some participants felt that the regulation system had failed news organisations by not protecting IP enough and worried that this would lead to a collapse of more news organisations which would then lead to undermining the AI models themselves. A point was made that much of news is based on so-called derivative content and thus based on the work of others, so news organisations have always done this and therefore need to acknowledge that first, before lecturing to tech companies.
The importance of dialogue between regulators, news organisations and tech companies was a recurring theme, especially as existing regulations may not be sufficient to address the challenges and speed of developments posed by AI. Is there a way to co-regulate holistically? Alexandru Giboi of The European Alliance of News Agencies made the point that more mutual understanding between tech & media companies could lead to better problem-solving in the future.
-- Play
-- --
There was a sidebar on the value of news: to society and also to tech companies. An observation was made that tech companies value news using the metric of revenue to them (which is de minimis) while news organisations judge their value in terms of societal value and importance to democracy. Thus, if the two sides are using different measures, they will never agree.
If news organisations believed they were so important to democracy, then they were challenged to try to speak with one voice to regulators as otherwise, their perspectives would not be understood nor factored in well enough. The difficulty is that there are multiple views on the multiple issues, including from within a single news organisation so getting to a singular would be very, very hard. But perhaps the potential existential challenge faced by the news ecosystem would drive different, more collaborative behaviour than in the past. And news organisations were also advised not to be slow, as it had been in the past.
In terms of solutions, a few were discussed, including:
Public education initiatives to raise awareness of AI and its potential pitfalls.
Investment in media literacy programs to help people critically evaluate information online.
Development of new economic models for the media industry that can thrive in the digital age.
Finding a balance between technological advancement, ethical considerations, and media viability will be crucial in the years to come in finding the right regulation to regulate AI and the news ecosystem.
Madhav Chinnappa Thomson Talks
Madhav Chinnappa, the former Director of News Ecosystem Development at Google and veteran news executive, leads our Thought Leadership events Thomson Talks.
Explore our projects across the globe
LINK: | http://www.thomsonfoundation.org/latest/finding-a-balance-as-ai-advanc... |
See more stories from thompsonfoundation |
Europe Stories
09/12/2024
Dalet Named an IDC Innovator in Media and Entertainment
Dalet, a leading technology and service provider for media-rich organizations, today announced that it has been named an IDC Innovator in the IDC Innovators: ...
09/11/2024
Dalet Expands Leadership Team to Fuel Next Stage of Growth
Dalet, a leading technology and service provider for media-rich organizations, today announced three new members of its executive team. Tara Bryant joins as Chi...
17/10/2024
It's Never Too Early To Spread Festive Cheer, Our Spotify Holiday Singles Are Here
The air is turning crisp, and it won't be long until everyone is walking aro...
17/10/2024
Coldplay Unites With Spotify and FC Barcelona To Release a Special El Clsico Shirt, Merch Collection, and Matchday Playlist
Spotify is once again collaborating with record-breaking legends from the worlds...
17/10/2024
Gold Medal Gymnast Rebeca Andrade Gives Us a Peek at Her Spotify
Rebeca Andrade knows her way around the gym floor . . . and vault, and uneven bars, and balance beam. The 25-year-old is the most decorated Latin American gymna...
17/10/2024
Your Exclusive Look Inside Our Charli xcx and Troye Sivan SWEAT Tour Afterparty
Since Charli xcx and Troye Sivan kicked off SWEAT, their joint tour of North America, in September, the live shows have become part of the cultural canon. Toget...
17/10/2024
Last Cut Media Increases EditShare Footprint to Streamline Production
Last Cut Media Increases EditShare Footprint to Streamline Production Adds capacity, AI indexing and sharing technologies Boston, MA, 17 October 2024 - EditS...
17/10/2024
BLAM vs BOLT: what's in a name?
Since its launch in 2020, Blue Lucy's flagship product, BLAM, has also been the company's only product. BLAM is a sophisticated workflow orchestration, ...
17/10/2024
Opinion: The transformative impact of remote production and cloud migration on the media industry
John Wastcoat, SVP business development and marketing at Zixi, highlights how me...
17/10/2024
How cinematographer Haris Zambarloukos captured the colour of Beetlejuice Beetlejuice
Zambarloukos details the cameras and lenses he used to capture Tim Burtons spook...
17/10/2024
EMG/Gravity Media names Eamonn Curtin as chief commercial officer
He takes up the role immediately, having spent the past 10 years as global client director at EMG/Gravity Media By Jenny Priestley Published: October 17, 202...
17/10/2024
Council pulls plug on Mo-Sys Plumstead Power Station deal
Mo-Sys planned to refurbish the Grade II listed site, opening eight studio stages By Matthew Corrigan Published: October 17, 2024 Mo-Sys planned to refurb...
17/10/2024
VEON Files its 2023 Form 20-F
17 Oct 2024 VEON Files its 2023 Form 20-F Amsterdam, 17 October 2024, 20:45: VEON Ltd. (Nasdaq: VEON, Euronext Amsterdam: VEON), a global digital operator ( VE...
17/10/2024
DUNE: PROPHECY coming exclusively to Sky and NOW on November 18, as official trailer released
DUNE: PROPHECY coming exclusively to Sky and NOW on November 18, as official tra...
17/10/2024
Rohde & Schwarz achieves full coverage of Skylos test plan for NB-NTN devices, enabling SMS services
Rohde & Schwarz achieves full coverage of Skylos test plan for NB-NTN devices, e...
17/10/2024
RNZ Selects Dalet for New Editorial System
Dalet, a leading technology and service provider for media-rich organizations, today announced that RNZ has partnered with Dalet to transform its editorial syst...
17/10/2024
Blancco Launches Free ROI Calculator to Help Enterprises Quantify Financial and ESG Benefits of Data Erasure
Home News & Press Press Release Blancco Launches Free ROI Calculator to He...
17/10/2024
2024-10-16
For the first time, businesses of all sizes around the world - even those without a brick-and-mortar presence - can manage the way they appear to over 1 billion...
17/10/2024
Thales makes first shipment of 300 night vision goggles for French Army under Bi-NYX contract
Facebook Twitter LinkedIn French forces have received the first 300 Thales...
17/10/2024
Genelec opens new Seoul Experience Centre
Genelec opens new Seoul Experience Centre posted: 17/10/2024 Seoul, South Korea, October 2024....Genelec has added Seoul to its growing global network of ...
17/10/2024
Joe Duffy returns with the 18th season of The Meaning of Life'
Guests include Sin ad Burke, Bryan Dobson, Sonia O'Sullivan, Ricky Tomlinson, David Norris, Catherine Joyce Collins, Ronan Tynan, Olwen Fou r , Fintan O'...
17/10/2024
Hollywood actors Colin Farrell, Rupert Everett and Aidan Quinn among guests on this Friday's Late Late Show
Hollywood actors Colin Farrell, Rupert Everett and Aidan Quinn among guests on t...
16/10/2024
New role at Thomson for Federica Varalda
We are pleased to announce that Federica Varalda has been appointed as Managing Director - Development for the Thomson Group. She will be leading project develo...
16/10/2024
It's Never Too Early To Spread Festive Cheer-Our Spotify Holiday Singles Are Here
The air is turning crisp, and it won't be long until everyone is walking aro...
16/10/2024
Setting Dynamic DNS (DDNS) On A Siretta Router
Applicable Products Part number Description QUARTZ-22-LTE (EU) Dual Port Dual SIM LTE Router (EU) QUARTZ-22-UMTS (EU) Dual Port Dual SIM UMTS Rout...
16/10/2024
Chayse Irvin, ASC, CSC on Travis Scott's Mo City Flexologist
Director Kahlil Joseph's name is just as likely to appear in world-renowned art exhibitions as it is atop the credits for lauded music videos. In the latter...
16/10/2024
Kunstmin Theater in Dordrecht Chooses Clear-Com Arcadia for Communication Revolution
eds3_5_jq(document).ready(function($) { $(#eds_sliderM519).chameleonSlider_2_1({...
16/10/2024
ARRI launches 14-strong Ens Prime lens range
Ens lenses feature a magnification ratio of 1:4 on most focal lengths, equivalent to 10 close focus on the 32mm, which, said the company, is only 3.7 from the ...
16/10/2024
Thales demonstrates its capacity to deploy drone swarms with unparalleled levels of autonomy using AI
Facebook Twitter LinkedIn On 16 October 2024, in the first flight tests of...
16/10/2024
Riedel Communications Appoints Jason Barden as Regional Sales Director for CALA/LATAM Market
Wuppertal October 16, 2024 Riedel Communications Appoints Jason Barden as Regi...
16/10/2024
MP visits unique Northern Ireland transmitter site
Sorcha Eastwood MP visits transmitting station, highlighting personal and national importance of broadcast infrastructure October 15, 2024: Sorcha Eastwood, MP...
16/10/2024
IFABC Elects New President and Secretary at 31st General Assembly
This biennial event brings together IFABC members from around the world to meet and share ideas, news and developments in media auditing and digital advertising...
16/10/2024
ESA orders 6 additional radar-based satellites to Thales Alenia Space for IRIDE Earth observation constellation
Facebook Twitter LinkedIn This new batch of radar satellites will also be ...
16/10/2024
RT's exciting slate of homegrown content for children
Over 110 hours of new video and podcast content commissioned in 2024 for Ireland's youngest citizens and their families -RT jr podcast turned TV series Mad...
16/10/2024
RT is looking for a new member of the RT Audience Council
RT is looking for a new member to join the RT Audience Council which helps us understand the views of our diverse audiences. RT is required to appoint an Au...
16/10/2024
German Armed Forces receive final Ground Alerter 10 sense and warn camp protection system
Facebook Twitter LinkedIn On 16 October 2024, Thales officially handed ove...
15/10/2024
Music Videos in Beta Brings an Improved Viewing Experience to New Markets
Earlier this year, Spotify introduced music videos in beta, giving Premium subscribers in 12 markets another way to connect with the songs and artists they love...
15/10/2024
Revisit Some of Music's Most Iconic Hits With Our Spotify Anniversaries' Video Series
Music serves as a powerful memory booster, and Spotify recently introduced a new...
15/10/2024
Viasat Selects ST Engineering iDirect's Next-Generation Ground Technology to Accelerate Customers' Digital Transformation
Long-term partnership expands with new technology, paving the way for further ef...
15/10/2024
Making the dragons fly
Martin Pelletier, visual effects supervisor at Rodeo FX, explains how House of the Dragon's fantastic flying beasts are able to take to the air By Matthew ...
15/10/2024
Adobe adds Gen AI video extension capabilities to Premiere Pro
The company has also unveiled updates to Frame.io and plans to help 30 million people develop AI literacy and content creation skills by 2030 By Jenny Priestle...
15/10/2024
Watch: What caught our AI at IBC
Watch a panel featuring TVBEuropes content director Jenny Priestley discuss some of the biggest talking points from IBC2024 By TVBEurope Staff Published: Oct...
15/10/2024
Ofcom extends Channel 4's licence for a further decade
The new licence is designed to support Channel 4's digital content and distribution strategy, while safeguarding its investment in UK content, said Ofcom B...
15/10/2024
Mid-Month Drop: AEAF Awards, Dark Matter, NHL 25, Saudi Film Confex, and more.
We're halfway through a thrilling October, so it's time to take a beat and celebrate our wicked achievements so far. Caroline Parot, CEO Technicolor G...
15/10/2024
Rohde & Schwarz drives AirFuel Alliance RF standardization efforts with first RF wireless power tester prototype
Rohde & Schwarz drives AirFuel Alliance RF standardization efforts with first RF...
15/10/2024
HMS Networks changes organization to strengthen customer focus and cross-selling
HMS Networks changes organization to strengthen customer focus and cross-selling 15 Oct 2024 at 07:30 GMT+2 Regulatory press release HMS Networks AB (publ)...
15/10/2024
2024-10-15
CUPERTINO, CALIFORNIA Apple today introduced the new iPad mini, supercharged by the A17 Pro chip and Apple Intelligence, the easy-to-use personal intelligence s...
15/10/2024
Thales radios successfully tested by the German Armed Forces to be deployed within the NATO enhanced Forward Presence
Facebook Twitter LinkedIn The German Armed Forces conducted operational te...
15/10/2024
KNDS selects Thales Power Systems Solution for the Leopard 2 A8
Facebook Twitter LinkedIn KNDS awarded Thales a contract to deliver compact, programable and scalable High-Power Solid-State Power Distribution Boards (SS...
15/10/2024
Thales Alenia Space signs a contract with OHB to develop two radar instruments for ESA's 10th exciting new Earth Explorer Harmony mission
Facebook Twitter LinkedIn Leveraging its longstanding experience in radar-...