Sony Pixel Power calrec Sony

European Court: Linking by framing is not a copyright infringement

30/10/2014

The facts of the case

The case concerns the use of a 2-minute long promotional video clip about water pollution, created by BestWater International, which produces and sells water filters. The video appeared on YouTube, apparently without knowledge or authorisation by BestWater, and was used by a competitor, who linked to the clip by means of framing , thereby making the clip visible on its own website. BestWater claimed copyright infringement of its clip and sought an injunction from the German courts. The defendant had meanwhile voluntarily ceased the use of the clip and the procedure was therefore limited to the restitution of damages.

The question referred to the CJEU by the German Supreme Court

Does the embedding, within one's own website, of another person's work made available to the public on a third-party website, in circumstances such as those in the main proceedings, constitute communication to the public within the meaning of Article 3(1) of the 2001 Copyright Directive (2001/29/EC), even where that other person's work is not thereby communicated to a new public and the communication of the work does not use a specific technical means which differs from that of the original communication?

In the Svensson case (C 466/12), where the European Court ruled on (mere) hyperlinking, the question of whether the link created the impression that the framed work would be appearing on the third party's website (thus concealing its original website) was held as not relevant. The Court held the decisive issue to be the same in the BestWater case, prompting it to answer negatively.

The framing of a work (or other protected material) which is freely available on a publicly accessible website is thus allowed, unless it is directed at a different audience than originally intended or is communicated (to the same audience or not) by using different technical means.

Comments

The Courts decision raises several issues and questions remain unaddressed.

First of all, one would have hoped that the Court had seized this opportunity to differentiate its reasoning in the Svensson case and clearly distinguish between (mere) hyperlinking and framing. In the Svensson case, the Court determined that any form of hyperlink is in principle subject to the communication to the public right unless there is no new public . This reasoning seems very far-reaching given that a hyperlink is, as such, no more than a technical tool to switch from one URL address to another. By contrast, the framing technique (in particular of audio or video streams provided by another website) is markedly different from hyperlinking, because in this case the end-user is not directed to the webpage where the original content is placed. That makes this type of communication more clearly an economic form of exploitation, which is a crucial distinction. This follows on from the Courts decision in the TVCatchup case (C-607/11), where for the question whether the third-party's re-use of a broadcast programme was a communication under Art. 3 of the 2001 Copyright Directive the question of a "new public" was not held relevant.

Moreover, it is difficult to accept the idea that a general allowance for embedding or framing protected material found elsewhere on the Internet would create the possibility of unauthorised usage, going far beyond the boundaries of any limitation or exception under copyright. In particular, the lawful quotation of another's work is subject to relatively strict conditions. These are tested by the special characteristics of the Internet, but the careful legislative balance underlying the quotation exception is bypassed entirely if third-party use is simply not held to be a relevant act of communication. It would have been more appropriate to consider that embedding or framing are always copyright relevant communications and lawful only to the extent that their use is in line with the requirements of the quotation exception.

Secondly, the question of whether embedding copyrighted videos available on the Internet would ever be tantamount to copyright infringement remains open in cases where the source video was uploaded without permission of the right owner.

In this particular context, it is remarkable that the Court recognised, but did not validate, the BestWater's claim that it had not authorised the clip to be uploaded on YouTube, as this fact could, and arguably should, have been taken into account for the question of a new public . Also, the wording of the request for a preliminary ruling by the German Supreme Court explicitly referred to the given circumstances of the actual case. Did the Court wish to indicate that as long as the copyright owner had not ordered YouTube to take the clip down it was considered tolerated and thereby lawfully available for everyone's free (embedding) use? And what if, though such a take-down order had been given, the clip re-appeared on YouTube or any other social network, as is often the case? It is difficult to imagine that the Court wished to suggest that the lawfulness of the first uploading of the original content is entirely irrelevant.

Finally, the lawfulness of embedding copyright-protected content subject to conditional access, e.g. the website hosting the source video was protected by a technological measure designed to prevent or restrict access, was not addressed. The C More Entertainment case (C-279/13) which involves such situation is still pending before the European Court.

Share this page on

--
LINK: http://www3.ebu.ch/contents/news/2014/10/european-court-linking-by-fra...
See more stories from ebu

Most recent headlines

21/12/2024

L3Harris Thrusters Position NASA Probe for Closest Approaches to the Sun

Artist's concept of the Parker Solar Probe spacecraft approaching the sun. Credit: NASA/Johns Hopkins APL...

21/12/2024

Dallas Mavericks Roll Out New Streaming Platform

DALLAS and NEW YORK The NBA's Dallas Mavericks, working with Endeavor Streaming, Softtek and the NBA, have launched an official streaming platform for MavsT...

21/12/2024

Former FCC Chair Expresses Concern' Over Musk's Influence

As tech billionaire Elon Musk takes an increasingly high-profile policy role in the incoming Trump administration, a former Federal Communications Commission ch...

21/12/2024

Gray Media Renews Comscore Measurement Deal

RESTON, Va. Comscore has announced that it has renewed and expanded its measurement deal with Gray Media....

21/12/2024

Sinclair, Gray Media to Broadcast Columbus Blue Jackets NHL Games

The Columbus Blue Jackets, Sinclair and FanDuel Sports Network have signed a deal that will allow Sinclair and Gray Media stations in select markets to simulcas...

21/12/2024

Our Favorite Songs of 2024

Our Favorite Songs of 2024 Explore a playlist featuring some of the top songs of the year, as picked by members of the Berklee community. By Tara Bellucci De...

21/12/2024

Berklee Wrapped 2024: Our Top News and Stories

Berklee Wrapped 2024: Our Top News and Stories Take a look at some of our best stories of the year, including announcing our next president, hosting Andr 300...

21/12/2024

Alumna Allison de Groot Awarded 2024 Steve Martin Banjo Prize

Alumna Allison de Groot Awarded 2024 Steve Martin Banjo Prize De Groot, a former student of the American Roots Music Program, was recognized for her unique so...

20/12/2024

Thinking of Launching a Podcast? Let Our New Guide Show You How

Podcasting has become one of the most popular ways to tell stories and connect with audiences, but getting started can be intimidating, especially when it comes...

20/12/2024

2025 Sundance Film Festival Reveals 92 Projects for Feature Film and Episodic Programs

Top L-R: The Legend of Ochi, Rabbit Trap, East of Wall, Seeds Center Row L-R: Re...

20/12/2024

Spotify Presents the First-Ever Billions Club Live Show With The Weeknd

For any song to rack up billions of streams is an impressive accomplishment, but being a part of Spotify's Billions Club is something The Weeknd knows quite...

20/12/2024

Curl Up Under the Mistletoe With These Holiday Romance Audiobooks

It's the most wonderful time of the year, but if you seek an escape, pop in your headphones and enjoy the soothing sounds of a story. And this season, a rom...

20/12/2024

Revisit 2024 With Some of Your Favorite Podcasts From The Ringer

As the year draws to a close, Spotify's The Ringer is celebrating the best of 2024 with an exciting lineup of retrospective podcast episodes. This December,...

20/12/2024

HPA Award Delivered To New Zealand!

HPA Award Committee co-founder Carolyn Giardina was in New Zealand recently and had the opportunity present the Outstanding Visual Effects - Live Action Feature...

20/12/2024

2025 HPA Tech Retreat Reveals Additional Unmissable Programming and Activities

On its 30th anniversary this year, one constant of the HPA Tech Retreat is its unique and consistently engaging programming that goes hand in hand with unparall...

20/12/2024

Seth Hallen Looks Back Over Nine Years As HPA President And Toward The Organization's Bright Future

Seth Hallen had been on the board for seven years before being named president i...

20/12/2024

Berkeley Repertory Theatre and Clear-Com Partnership Refines Communication for...

eds3_5_jq(document).ready(function($) { $(#eds_sliderM519).chameleonSlider_2_1({...

20/12/2024

Clear-Com Provides Communication Solutions at the 2024 Singapore Airlines Formula 1...

eds3_5_jq(document).ready(function($) { $(#eds_sliderM519).chameleonSlider_2_1({...

20/12/2024

Sport Lisboa e Benfica Enhances Stadium Communications with Clear-Com's Arcadia...

eds3_5_jq(document).ready(function($) { $(#eds_sliderM519).chameleonSlider_2_1({...

20/12/2024

Calrec recognised in Feed's Honours List

FEED Honours List | Calrec recognised by FEED for outstanding contribution to sports broadcast FEED's sports broadcast segment Xtreme is taking this opport...

20/12/2024

If you're IP and you know it, clap your hands

If you're IP and you know it, clap your hands (First published by TVB Europe) By Sid Stanley, General Manager at Calrec To mark World Television Day, Calr...

20/12/2024

Sunbeam Television and Nielsen Renew Local TV Measurement Agreement

Multi-year deal includes Local TV and OTT measurement for stations in Boston and Miami Nielsen's Local TV measurement backed by Big Data + Panel NEW YORK ...

20/12/2024

Netflix Scores U.S. Rights to FIFA Women's World Cup

LOS GATOS, Calif. In a historic deal for women's soccer and major sports on streaming services, Netflix has secured the exclusive U.S. rights to the Women&#...

20/12/2024

NextGen TV: The Push Is On

It's sometimes said that trying to get a group of broadcasters to do anything is like trying to herd cats, but if 2025 plays out as some broadcasters hope t...

20/12/2024

Feature Film Mind Body Spirit Captured and Graded with Blackmagic Design

Feature Film Mind Body Spirit Captured and Graded with Blackmagic Design Brie Clayton December 20, 2024 0 Comments Filmmakers create found footage loo...

20/12/2024

Berklee's Music Business/Management Department Partners with Vistex

Berklee's Music Business/Management Department Partners with Vistex The partnership will provide students with hands-on experience using the company's...

20/12/2024

Latin Grammy Cultural Foundation Announces 2025 Warner Music Latina Scholarship

Latin Grammy Cultural Foundation Announces 2025 Warner Music Latina Scholarship The scholarship will cover tuition and room and board for the 2025 fall semester...

20/12/2024

WRAZ Raleigh Adopts Advanced HDR by Technicolor for ATSC 3.0 Transmission

RALEIGH, N.C. WRAZ, the Capitol Broadcasting-owned Fox affiliate here, is transmitting content in high dynamic range (HDR) to ATSC 3.0 viewers using Advanced HD...

20/12/2024

Global Virtual Reality Shipments Totaled Nearly 10 Million in 2024

Global shipments of virtual reality and mixed reality headsets are expected to reach approximately 9.6 million units in 2024, representing a year-over-year incr...

20/12/2024

Florida Launches AI-Powered Emergency Communications System

Emergency management officials in Florida are harnessing the power of artificial intelligence to better protect residents from the threat of hurricanes and othe...

20/12/2024

Blackmagic Design Adds Icon View, Other Features to Blackmagic Cloud

FREMONT, Calif. Blackmagic Design today unveiled new features for its Blackmagic Cloud, including a new icon view with thumbnails that can be scrubbed to previe...

20/12/2024

Japanese Anime Animated $19.8 Billion in Global Revenue in 2023

TOKYO A new study highlights the growing importance of Japanese anime in both the entertainment and streaming industries, with Parrot Analytics reporting the ge...

20/12/2024

Canada's Sportsnet Launches Mobile Gaming During Live NHL Telecasts

MESA, Ariz. In a notable example of how networks are looking to provide interactive experiences in live sports broadcasts to boost engagement and ad revenue, mo...

20/12/2024

Goal: Liverpool (assist: Wasabi)

Liverpool Football Club produces over 100 pieces of content every week across its linear TV channel, OTT platform and social media channels. LFC's Drew Cris...

20/12/2024

How AI is reshaping media workflows and competitive strategies

Media Excel CEO Narayanan Rajan ponders whether AI will be the catalyst for medias future, and suggests that companies need to embrace AI today or risk falling ...

20/12/2024

Catching the Christmas train

Filming one of the world's most scenic rail routes in the depths of winter needed a planning operation that was second to none. Sohail Shah, MD of King of S...

20/12/2024

Renderboxes unveils Photon transportable workstation

Compatible with the latest Nvidia RTX GPU, Photon delivers HEPC performance in a transportable chassis By Matthew Corrigan Published: December 20, 2024 Co...

20/12/2024

DCMS announces Creative Industries Taskforce members

The taskforce will inform the Creative Industries Sector Plan, which aims to boost economic growth under the wider Industrial Strategy By Matthew Corrigan Pu...

20/12/2024

Watch: TVBEurope's Story of 2024

TVBEurope takes its annual look back at the biggest events in the media and entertainment industry during 2024, from the rise of AI to major live events, its be...

20/12/2024

SES's Seventh and Eighth O3b mPOWER Satellites Successfully Launched, Bolstering MEO Constellation

Additional satellites bring incremental capacity to scale up services provided b...

20/12/2024

AI Is a Tool, Not a Creative Solution

AI Is a Tool, Not a Creative Solution Andy Marken December 19, 2024 0 Comments What you men call work life' is full of flattery and peer pressur...

20/12/2024

Blackmagic URSA Cine Immersive is Available to Pre-Order from Blackmagic Design

Blackmagic URSA Cine Immersive is Available to Pre-Order from Blackmagic Design Brie Clayton December 19, 2024 0 Comments Blackmagic URSA Cine Immersi...

20/12/2024

Covert Welcomes Mixed-Media Studio Aniverse into Family

Covert Welcomes Mixed-Media Studio Aniverse into Family Brie Clayton December 19, 2024 0 Comments UK-based creative studio Covert is thrilled to annou...

20/12/2024

The CFP Battle Begins: ESPN Covers First Round With Various MegaCast Options, Compact Tech Plan, Team Insights on Conference Networks

The CFP Battle Begins: ESPN Covers First Round With Various MegaCast Options, Co...

20/12/2024

SVG Summit 2024: Tata Communications' Elio Parente on Tapping Into the Company's Media Cloud Infrastructure

SVG Summit 2024: Tata Communications' Elio Parente on Tapping Into the Compa...

20/12/2024

SVG Summit 2024: LTN's Colin Moran on Enabling Customers to Maintain Higher Content Visibility

SVG Summit 2024: LTN's Colin Moran on Enabling Customers to Maintain Higher ...

20/12/2024

SVG Summit 2024: When Sports Became News A Look at the Munich Massacre Through the Golden Globe-Nominated Film September 5

SVG Summit 2024: When Sports Became News A Look at the Munich Massacre Through...

20/12/2024

Netflix Snags Exclusive U.S. FIFA Women's World Cup Rights for 2027, 2031

Netflix Snags Exclusive U.S. FIFA Women's World Cup Rights for 2027, 2031 By Ken Kerschbaumer Friday, December 20, 2024 - 10:08 am Print This Story | ...

20/12/2024

SVTA Announces First Industry Group, The Streaming Sports Council, To Capture Key Technical Challenges in Live Sports Streaming

SVTA Announces First Industry Group, The Streaming Sports Council, To Capture Ke...

20/12/2024

Usyk v Fury 2: How DAZN Will Produce a Cinematic World Feed and Authentic' Unilateral Coverage From Riyadh

Usyk v Fury 2: How DAZN will produce a cinematic world feed and authentic' ...