Valley of The Gods, some of the public lands Utah legislators want to seize from the federal government | Photo: Bob Wick, BLM
Commentary: Utah's conservative politicians have been advocating the state seize federal lands for years. This year, the Utah legislature and governor have been pushing Utah Attorney General Sean Reyes to sue the federal government to hand over the 30 million acres of federal land within the state. The lawsuit has already cost the state $2 million, even though it hasnt yet been filed. It may never be filed. As of last Friday, Reyes hadn't made up his mind. If hes leaning toward dropping the matter, he just got some serious backup. A recent report by the Conference of Western Attorneys General, obtained by the Associated Press and publicized last week, suggests that the proposed lawsuit is based on shoddy legal arguments, misrepresentation or misunderstanding of the U.S. Constitution, and disregard for decades of Supreme Court decisions regarding public lands.
That report almost certainly won't sway advocates of devolving federal lands to the states, part of a decades-old movement whose members have their own private understanding of western history and federal law. You've probably heard of two recent campaigns by members of that movement: the 2016 occupation of the Malheur National Wildlife Refuge, and the 2014 confrontation over illegally grazed cattle from the Cliven Bundy ranch in Nevada.
But to really understand the movement propelling Utah's attempted lawsuit, it's useful to consider an act of domestic terrorism that happened 21 years ago on American soil, which you've probably never heard of.
--
--
The Attorneys General's report doesn't contain much in the way of surprises: it's a thorough debunking of assertions about the constitution and federal case law made by people who want to get the feds out of the land protection business. Those anti-environmental activists claim the Constitution grants no authority to the federal government to own land in perpetuity, and that those public lands are rightfully the property of the states, which could sell those lands to private parties and thereby accomplish two things: 1) generate revenues for the state by selling the land, and 2) allow unrestricted exploitation of the land's resources for private profit.
Related
Court: State Can Limit Gold Mining Despite 19th Century Law
Feds OK Huge, Controversial Solar Project Near Mojave Preserve
Find Your New Favorite Park with FindYourPark.com
1 of 4
next
While the report doesn't offer a slam dunk rebuttal to those claims - the Supreme Court has never directly ruled on the legality of the federal government owning land in perpetuity - it is an exhaustive, authoritative counter to the claims of public land opponents, including the Utah legislature. The fact that the report is offered by the lead attorneys for the very states that would, theoretically, benefit from devolving federal lands to the states is especially devastating.
The sad thing: the people pushing for that devolution almost certainly won't agree. Social media analysts increasingly talk about the political bubbles we create, in which we're protected from opinions contrary to our own. Public land opponents conduct their affairs in the mother of all political bubbles, protected from contrary arguments, established caselaw, American history, and in too many cases, compassion for the people they disagree with, and for those people's families. And there's no better example of the latter than the terrorist attacks on a U.S. Forest Service ranger in 1995 in Nevada.
On March 30, 1995, someone placed a pipe bomb at the Carson City, Nevada office of Toiyabe National Forest district ranger Guy Pence. It exploded before Pence arrived for work the next day. No one was injured. A few weeks later, a bomb of substantially similar design exploded under Pence's van, parked in the driveway at his home. Pence wasn't home, but his wife and one of his kids were. They escaped injury by a stroke of luck: neither were sitting on the living room couch showered with broken glass and debris by the explosion.
Guy Pence, working on the Deepwater Horizon oil spill response in Louisiana in 2010 | Photo: USFWS
No one has ever been charged with the 1995 bombings, though investigators did not lack for persons of interest. Pence, by enforcing federal law managing grazing and mining in the Toiyabe, had incurred the wrath of any number of people accustomed to using public lands as their own personal fiefdoms. Always present in the west, the numbers of people opposed to any federal management of public lands exploitation grew dramatically during the 1970s' Sagebrush Rebellion, an explicitly anti-environmental movement that started in reaction to proposed Wilderness designations. Rural Nevada was and is rife with Sagebrush Rebels. Many, perhaps most, are essentially decent people. But their ranks include a number of activists allied with some of the worst elements of American society.
The Sagebrush Rebellion's main gripe in the 70s was a federal review of large, unroaded areas of public land, which were to be considered for wilderness designation. The so-called Roadless Area Review and Evaluation (RARE) process eventually recommended that 15 million acres of national forests be designated as Wilderness, and described an additional 10 million acres (and change) that merited further consideration for the same protection.
Wilderness designation blocks many forms of resource exploitation the Sagebrush Rebels held dear - though, notably, it doesn't prevent livestock grazing. Between the RARE programs and a 1976 law, the Federal Land Policy and Management Act (FLPMA), which formally abolished the Homestead Acts allowing private citizens to c
Most recent headlines
17/02/2025
TVBEurope talks to the team who brought a piece of broadcasting history back to life on BBC Wales last night
By Jenny Priestley
Published: February 14, 2025 ...
17/02/2025
Eligible studios will receive the relief directly from their local authorities, with no need to submit a claim
By Matthew Corrigan
Published: February 17, 20...
17/02/2025
As DEI initiatives come under pressure in the USA, supporters of Rise, which promotes diversity in the media and entertainment sector, discuss the continuing im...
17/02/2025
EIB Global loan will partially fund SES's continued O3b mPOWER medium earth orbit (MEO) fleet expansion enabling additional capacity worldwide. O3b mPOWER s...
15/02/2025
At Nielsen, Business Resource Groups (BRGs) play a critical role in nurturing a ...
15/02/2025
Innovation to empower creativity: Explore the latest in Lightroom
Rob Christensen February 15, 2025
0 Comments
Whether you want to remove distracting ...
15/02/2025
Wisycom, a worldwide leader in RF technology and provider of wireless solutions, announces a new distribution agreement with EQUAPHON. An Argentinian profession...
15/02/2025
DPA Microphones, the leading manufacturer of high-quality microphone solutions, is pleased to welcome Nicholas Nick Mariano and Vincent Vince Divine to the ...
15/02/2025
Tuxera, a leading provider of quality-assured file systems and networking solutions, will showcase how Tuxera Fusion SMB enables unprecedented performance for m...
15/02/2025
Bitmovin's latest Video Developer Report indicates an increasing role of AI, the slow adoption of next-generation codecs, and continuing challenges when it ...
15/02/2025
When Michelin Enterprises set out to promote its prestigious Hotel Guide in the new Sleepless in the Kitchen , campaign, veteran German/Slovenian gaffer Robert...
15/02/2025
Formula E, the world's first all-electric racing series, revolutionizing motorsport with cutting-edge technology and a commitment to sustainability has sele...
15/02/2025
Agile Content, a global leader in TV and video technology solutions, announces its rebranding to AgileTV.
The transition to AgileTV stems from a commitment to ...
15/02/2025
Hiltron Communications will promote the latest additions to its range of satellite communication products, systems and supporting services at GovSatCom 2025. Th...
15/02/2025
Following the success of the original Airglow Booklight, DoPchoice debuts a new addition to their inflatable line the Float. This lightweight, inflatable, round...
15/02/2025
LAS VEGAS Marshall Electronics has announced that it will debut its newest camera controller, the RCP Plus, at the 2025 NAB Show at Booth N2649 between April 5 ...
15/02/2025
ATLANTA Gray Media has named Blake Sebo as the next general manager of KTUU and KYES, Gray's NBC and CBS affiliates in Anchorage, Alaska....
15/02/2025
KOKKEDAL, Denmark DPA Microphones will feature its new CORE+ technology for distortion-free microphone sound at the 2025 NAB Show, April 5-9, in Las Vegas....
15/02/2025
SWANSEA, U.K. QuickLink will launch StudioPro-NDI and StudioPro-3, two new models of its QuickLine StudioPro video production platform, at the 2025 NAB Show, Ap...
15/02/2025
Live From 2025 NBA All-Star Game Weekend: After 25 Years, Turner Sports All-In F...
15/02/2025
NASCAR Driver Cam on Max Embraces Cloud-Based Workflow for 2025 Season Chris Brown of WBD Sports says Mobii will play key part in delivering signals from the tr...
14/02/2025
Last month, we officially launched the Spotify Partner Program, a powerful new m...
14/02/2025
From an island off the coast of Lutruwita to the global stage in France SBS & ...
14/02/2025
The future of electro-optical/infrared (EO/IR) land systems is evolving so that ...
14/02/2025
Here are 5 reasons why you should attend ISE 2025
Discover more about Calrec: Learn more about Calrec's legacy of innovation in broadcast audio solutions ...
14/02/2025
World Radio Day: On the same wavelength
By Graham Murray, International Sales Manager at Calrec
To mark World Radio Day, Calrec's International Sales Ma...
14/02/2025
DALLAS and TYSONS, Va. Tegna has concluded a broadcast rights agreement that makes Tegna's KFAA in Dallas the exclusive local television partner of the Dall...
14/02/2025
Amazon's Prime Video has released a new app for Apple TV that the streamer said delivers an improved streaming experiences with faster scrolling, improved s...
14/02/2025
CLEVELAND Telos Alliance announced a software update for its Axia Quasar XR and SR line of audio-over-IP (AoIP) mixing consoles and will show the offering at th...
14/02/2025
Puget Systems Returns to HPA Tech Retreat 2025 with New Analysis Tools for Puge...
14/02/2025
Glass Animals: Tour of Earth Uses Blackmagic Live Production Workflow
Brie Clayton February 14, 2025
0 Comments
80six deploys Blackmagic URSA Broadcas...
14/02/2025
A dispute between Paramount and Youtube TV that would have pulled CBS stations and Paramount's cable channels from the streaming service has been temporaril...
14/02/2025
Colourist Deidre (Dee) McClelland details how she helped shape the distinct look and feel of whimsical Oscar-nominated stop-motion film, Memoir of a Snail
By C...
14/02/2025
BitFire said it intends to introduce forward-looking services that simplify the launch of live production workflows, and enhance real-time collaboration
By Jen...
14/02/2025
The claim by the liquidators is the latest twist in the ongoing saga of the companys collapse at the end of 2021
By Matthew Corrigan
Published: February 14, ...
14/02/2025
A carriage dispute between YouTube TV and Paramount could come to a head today (Feb. 13), with the virtual pay TV provider threatening to pull all of the progra...
14/02/2025
ENGLEWOOD CLIFFS, N.J. LG Electronics USA has opened a new in-house, state-of-the-art virtual production studio at its 360,000-square-foot North American headqu...
14/02/2025
NEW YORK In a bid to help local broadcasters find new ways of monetizing their content, the Coalition for Innovative Media Measurement (CIMM) and TVB have relea...
14/02/2025
WASHINGTON Three Democratic U.S. Senators have sent a stern letter blasting FCC Chair Brendan Carr for the weaponization of the agency for attacking broadcast...
14/02/2025
Years after launching the streaming service Apple TV+ in November of 2019, Apple has finally released a version of its steaming app for Android devices....
14/02/2025
FOOTHILL RANCH, Calif. Red Digital Cinema will make its V-RAPTOR [X] and KOMODO-X camera systems available with Nikon's premier Z Mount, providing filmmaker...
14/02/2025
DAYTONA, Fla. The Fox Sports production of this year's Daytona 500 will see the addition of a few new tech elements and the continued unfolding of the broad...
14/02/2025
Watch Bryson Battles Blind Audition on The Voice Get a Four-Chair Turn Michael Bubl said the Boston Conservatory at Berklee musical theater senior might have...
14/02/2025
2025 Daytona 500: FOX Sports Looks To Ride Super Bowl LIX Momentum Into NASCAR S...
14/02/2025
14 Feb 2025
VEON's Kyivstar and the Come Back Alive Foundation Raise USD 2....
14/02/2025
Max Renews THE PITT, Starring Noah Wyle, For A Second Season
Max
Warner Bros. Television Group
The Pitt
New Episodes Of The Medical Drama From John...
14/02/2025
This year, Technicolor proudly celebrates 110 years of shaping the magic of cinema pioneering color, visual effects, and innovation that bring unforgettable l...
14/02/2025
NBA All-Star: More Games, More Teams, More Music, More Sound From the Court Turner Sports' team will deploy familiar tech to capture all the audio By Dan D...
14/02/2025
LIV Golf Continues To Innovate With Drones, Data-Driven Graphics, and All-Access...
Valley of The Gods, some of the public lands Utah legislators want to seize from the federal government | Photo: Bob Wick, BLM 
