Opinions are still flying over the fall schedules unveiled by the broadcast networks at last months upfront presentations. As the marketplace is digesting all of the strategic moves and fresh content, some of the most valuable opinions belong to media agencies, who will be advising clients in the process of spending billions on commercial time during the upfront buying process. With marketers and their agencies having more programming choices than ever before, the broadcast networks are under mounting pressure to come up with shows that viewers want to watch and make their advertisers happy.
As we have done annually during the past several upfronts, B&C gathered three veteran media agency executives and tossed 10 questions at them based on some of the key broadcast network moves. The execs are: Billie Gold, VP-director of programming research at Dentsu Aegis Amplifi US; Brian Hughes, senior VP, audience analysis practice lead, Magna Global; and Dave Campanelli, senior VP, director of national broadcast, Horizon Media.
Related: Upfronts 2016: CBS Schedule Favors Comedy, Consistency
Part 1 of this two-part conversation will cover topics like holding back more new shows for mid-season premieres rather than fall debuts, networks decision to add more comedy and to bring back reworked past hits to their schedules, and to continuing to offer increased diversity in new show casts. Edited excerpts of the email conversation follow.
The five major broadcast networks-with only 20 new shows scheduled to premiere in September-seem to be counting as much, if not more, on the second half of the season to put on some of their best new programming. Is this a strategy that can work for them, or will viewers watch broadcast in the fall, maybe tune out, and not return? Is it really better to hold back good shows for mid-season rather than putting them on in the fall?
Billie Gold: The biggest ratings makers, or hits, of the past two seasons have launched in midseason: Foxs Empire and NBCs Little Big Shots. By launching new product in midseason, networks avoid the flood of sampling in fall and, more importantly, competition from football. That being said, the networks are still launching much of their strongest fare in fall and by programming other strong contenders in midseason their hope is not to lose viewers to big cable launches in midseason, which is a good strategy. Viewers will tune in fall, winter, spring or summer if there is strong programming to see.
Brian Hughes: Todays viewing environment has put the broadcasters in a difficult position, especially considering they are held to a different standard than even their ad-supported cable counterparts. For a show to work, it has to toe the line between broad appeal and an audience-grabbing edge. The Walking Dead, for example, could never air on broadcast. Scheduling is one tactic the networks have been trying to figure out with mixed results. There seems to be a universal desire to have more first-run programming throughout the season, which can sometimes mean lengthy hiatuses between new episodes of a particular series. In terms of holding launches to midseason, I can see a couple of reasons this might be happening: First, TV usage is traditionally higher in first quarter (winter months). Second, It provides the opportunity to build promotional momentum, including the use of high-profile sporting events like the NFL and the World Series. Whether or not it will work remains to be seen. Were expecting continued linear TV declines, but theres always the possibility that a new show or two will catch on.
Dave Campanelli: I think viewers have been well trained to find the shows they want to watch, regardless of when they are launched. Cable premieres shows based on production timelines more than anything. I dont think it will hurt the networks to premiere more in the second half of the year.
Related: Upfronts 2016: ABC Ups Bet on Family Comedies
Broadcast networks continue to develop and put on their schedules more comedy. Has TV drama oversaturated primetime schedules and are comedies, particularly family-centric comedies, a way to draw some viewers back or keep them interested in broadcast? And are family-oriented comedies better suited for many advertisers?
Gold: I wouldnt say dramas have over-saturated the primetime schedule, I just think dramas have had slightly more success in recent years than comedies so theres more of them currently on air. Thats not for the lack of networks trying to launch successful comedies. They certainly have strived to do that. Launching a successful comedy can be extremely lucrative to a network and they repeat better than dramas, which is a big plus. Family-friendly comedies are always highly desirable to advertisers and the networks know it, so of course its a huge lure, albeit, Im not sure if the broadcast networks see comedies as a way to draw viewers back but rather a way to keep them, since cable doesnt offer as many alternatives in the genre.
Hughes: These things seem to be cyclical-schedules will be light on comedy for a few years and then suddenly there will be a big push. I think family comedies are the low-hanging fruit right now, because its what has worked the last few years, and typically offers the aforementioned broad appeal that the networks are looking for.
Related: Upfronts 2016: NBCU Throws Some Elbows, Widens Tent in First Unified Upfront Pitch
Campanelli: Any time there is an opportunity for co-viewing, there is a potential bump in audience because of it. ABC has been successful with shows like Modern Family, black-ish, The Middle, Fresh Off the Boat, etc., so there might be some mimicking there. Also, comedies play better in syndication, domestically at least, so that could play into it as well.
There are several former broadcast network series being brought back years later, some with new
Most recent headlines
02/01/2025
NextGen TV, aka ATSC 3.0, continued to advance in 2024, with some notable developments and renewed hopes that a deregulatory-minded Federal Communications Commi...
02/01/2025
Artificial intelligence is undoubtedly the hottest topic in the tech industry today, displaying all the excitement, apprehension and hype of the early days of t...
02/01/2025
STAMFORD, Conn. NBC Sports said 2024 was its best year in terms of ratings since 2016. Its success was fueled by the Paris Summer Olympics as well as its NFL co...
02/01/2025
MSG Networks has been dropped from Altice USA's Optimum-branded pay TV offerings after the operator and the regional sports provider were unable to reach a ...
02/01/2025
How color film and analog color TV works with bluescreen / chromakey
Graham Quince January 2, 2025
0 Comments
A deep dive into VFX History looking at ...
02/01/2025
Hulu Series Interior Chinatown Graded with DaVinci Resolve Studio
Brie Clayton January 2, 2025
0 Comments
Colorist Aidan Stanford delivers complex gra...
02/01/2025
Bulk Font Replacement in Premiere Pro
Andy Ford January 2, 2025
0 Comments
If you want to change the font of multiple text layers in Premiere Pro, the...
02/01/2025
Streaming media's impact on the media and entertainment industry continued to widen in 2024, as more sports rights moved to streaming platforms and the rapi...
02/01/2025
ATLANTA The board of directors for Gray Television Inc. has unanimously voted to change the company's name to Gray Media, Inc. effective Jan. 1....
02/01/2025
Official television and film archives exist to preserve the history and creativity of media. But even these formal institutions do not contain everything that h...
02/01/2025
Welsh succeeds Renard Jenkins, who has reached the end of his two-year tenure in the role
By Jenny Priestley
Published: January 2, 2025
Welsh succeeds Ren...
02/01/2025
Creator Economy Isn't Really Like Film/Show Entertainment
Andy Marken January 1, 2025
0 Comments
Come on Barry, you're good at this sort of s...
02/01/2025
Blackmagic Design Announces New Lower Price for Blackmagic Pocket Cinema Camera ...
02/01/2025
Hollywood Lighting Hacks: Big Looks, Tiny Budget
Sean Alami January 1, 2025
0 Comments
Discover how to create stunning Hollywood-style lighting using ...
02/01/2025
A fresh start to 2025 with new faces, familiar voices and plenty of Irish music ...
02/01/2025
GeForce NOW is kicking off 2025 by delivering 14 games to the cloud this month, with two available to stream this week so members can get started on their New Y...
01/01/2025
Marcy Lefkovitz, Dalet SVP product innovation, details the findings of the companys report into the future of newsrooms, including leveraging AI, optimising mul...
31/12/2024
Rashad Frett shares a moment with Michelle Satter at the 2023 Directors Lab. Pho...
31/12/2024
What's Ahead in 2025? OWC's Larry O'Connor Offers Some Bold Predicti...
31/12/2024
Blackmagic Design Announces New Features for Blackmagic Cloud
Brie Clayton December 31, 2024
0 Comments
New thumbnail icon view, clip metadata inspect...
31/12/2024
5 Features in DaVinci Resolve You're Not Using (But You Should Be)
Kasia Jarco December 31, 2024
0 Comments
In this video we are going to talk abo...
31/12/2024
Back to All News
NFL Christmas Day Games on Netflix Average Over 30 Million Global Viewers
Entertainment
31 December 2024
Global
Link copied to clipboard
...
31/12/2024
Back to All News
Squid Game' Season 2 Smashes Top 10 Records as Millions W...
30/12/2024
Leaving Thomson after 21 years, former Managing Director David Quin reflects on a career spent navigating the shifting sands of global media development. From r...
30/12/2024
[Pictured: a still from Love Lies Bleeding, one of the 100 Sundance-supported titles that opened to wider audiences in 2024]...
30/12/2024
Digital Domain Creates Groundbreaking VFX for Venom: The Last Dance, Bringing ...
30/12/2024
Internet Giant GMP Builds Tokyo Virtual Event Space with URSA Broadcast G2
Brie Clayton December 30, 2024
0 Comments
Blackmagic URSA Broadcast G2 and ...
30/12/2024
Renderboxes launches Photon, a no-compromise transportable high-performance work...
30/12/2024
Shinobi II Monitor Supports Canon, Sony, Nikon - Touch to Focus with New Feature...
30/12/2024
30 Dec 2024
In a Groundbreaking Agreement, VEON and Starlink to Bring Starlink ...
30/12/2024
The pace of technology innovation has accelerated in the past year, most dramati...
29/12/2024
Gyeongnam Culture and Arts Foundation (GCAF), an active promotor of cultural and artistic diversity, has chosen Ikegami UHK-X700 camera chains for integration i...
27/12/2024
After starting 2024 with hopes that the transition to streaming might finally produce a more stable, profitable businesses, the media and entertainment industry...
27/12/2024
Broadcasters ended the year with hopes and fears about how the federal government will regulate the TV industry in 2025. While the incoming Trump administration...
27/12/2024
NVIDIA's AI Podcast gives listeners the inside scoop on the ways AI is transforming nearly every industry. Since the show's debut in 2016, it's gar...
26/12/2024
Talking about artificial intelligence in 2024 is akin to talking about the internet in 1994 everyone's excited about it and thinks it will have an enormous ...
26/12/2024
Back to All News
Netflix NFL Christmas Gameday Reaches 65 Million US Viewers
Entertainment
26 December 2024
GlobalUnited States
Link copied to clipboard
U...
26/12/2024
Back to All News
Check Out All the Must-See Trailers From Netflix's NFL Chr...
26/12/2024
Back to All News
Beyonc Delivers Epic Gift of a Halftime Performance "Beyonc...
26/12/2024
Back to All News
Get in the Game With Squid Game' Season 2 Complete Coverage Guide
Entertainment
26 December 2024
Global
Link copied to clipboard
Are...
26/12/2024
This GFN Thursday wraps up another incredible year for cloud gaming. Take a look back at the top games and new features that made 2024 a standout for GeForce NO...
24/12/2024
The National Film and Video Foundation (NFVF) is calling for applications from South African film and television filmmakers to be part of the NFVF's delegat...
24/12/2024
WASHINGTON, D.C. The Federal Communications Commission Enforcement Bureau said Paramount Global is being fined $244,952 for violations of emergency alerting rul...
24/12/2024
NEW YORK Carnegie Hall's video-streaming channel, Carnegie Hall+, said it will celebrate the holiday season by offering a wide selection of holiday-themed o...
24/12/2024
LOS ANGELES PlayersTV, an athlete and fan-owned media company, has announced the acquisition of Cloud Media Center, an AI-driven sports adtech and media distrib...
24/12/2024
The Best Playlists of 2024 The top playlists we created in 2024, from dad rock to dembow.
By
Tara Bellucci
December 23, 2024
Image by Kelly Davidson
Tak...
24/12/2024
Editor's note: This post is part of the AI Decoded series, which demystifies AI by making the technology more accessible, and showcases new hardware, softwa...
23/12/2024
At IBC2024, Grass Valley CTO Ian Fletcher told attendees at GV Forum that broadcast is now an IT industry. During our discussions at the show, TVBEurope heard v...
23/12/2024
According to co-director Nick Park, the production team embraced technology to help create the iconic duos latest adventure
By Jenny Priestley
Published: Dec...
Opinions are still flying over the fall schedules unveiled by the broadcast networks at last months upfront presentations. As the marketplace is digesting all of the strategic moves and fresh content, some of the most valuable opinions belong to media agencies, who will be advising clients in the process of spending billions on commercial time during the upfront buying process. With marketers and their agencies having more programming choices than ever before, the broadcast networks are under mounting pressure to come up with shows that viewers want to watch and make their advertisers happy.
